Just think of the waste of public funds! And the injustice of it all!
The prosecutors are there … armed with piles of documents and information gathered at considerable effort and cost by taxpayer-paid staffs; the defendants are there … along with their expensive legal defence counsel, complete with piles of researched information, legal documents and briefs … often paid for by taxpayer-funded legal aid; the accused(sometimes innocent) is there, along with families and friends … taking time off work to support them; court security is there (sometimes more than one) …again paid for by taxpayers; and the judge is there …. very highly-paid, and well briefed by extensive legal research prepared by expert staff.
And then …the whole procedure is canceled … because there was no Court clerk available due to staff shortages!
Just think of the waste of public finds! And the injustice of it all! (That’s worth repeating because it is not just a one-time occurrence these days in BC’s “justice” system … it’s now happening more than most ever knew.)
So much so, in fact, that the Victoria Times-Colonist reported last week Justice Robert Johnston was forced to “shut down a complex trial because a Court clerk was not available”.
And that happened in a BC Supreme Court proceeding!
The Court clerk … a trained and sworn officer of the justice system …is an ESSENTIAL part of any Court proceeding: not just recording what happens, but handling evidence, stick-handling procedures and swearing in witnesses.
His Honour was not amused that there was NONE available.
“The Province of British Columbia has failed in its Constitutional obligation to properly fund the administration of justice,” the Justice complained publicly.
PUBLICLY! In Court! From the bench!
In fact, the Times-Colonist reported three other Supreme Court cases were also delayed for the same reason; and a Provincial Court courtroom was SHUT DOWN for the day due to lack of staff.
And that was just ONE day in ONE city.
Kudos o the Times-Colonist for shining the light on this disgraceful failure of BC’s justice system and the BC government; shame on the BC’s media that neglected the story completely or, even in mentioning it, failed to pursue with the Premier or the Justice Minister the issue of the HUMAN impact suffered by so many as a result.
Hard to imagine the total waste of taxpayers dollars being frittered away by those responsible for administering BC’s justice system!Not to mention …. yes, LET’S MENTION … the personal, financial waste and emotional impact on individuals and families and groups forced to deal with that system.
(Just think how the $11 MILLION spent on that Bollywood party could have helped out!)
Even when there ARE enough staff available, there are many, many people … especially victims … who see no justice in BCs justice system.
I have written about this SEVERAL times: on this blog; and when working I did a entire series entitled Contempt for Court that outlined a whole litany of problems and won a Websters’ Award.
But judging by the latest revelations … it’s getting even worse.
And the BC government should be held accountable for it.
(Reminder: You can First Alert notifications of new postings on this blog by following @harveyoberfeld on Twitter.
And please help stop Japan’s illegal slaughter of whales: read the labels and BOYCOTT Japanese products.)
Tags: British Columbia
Political junkies love elections: they can be so exciting … whether they take place at home, in other provinces, in states south of the border, in Canada or the U.S. or even in other countries.
How interested or worked up we get depends on the stakes as we perceive them, as we personally are impacted, or as they affect other provinces, states or countries that interest us.
I think about all that as I assess the outcome of this week’s two BC by-elections and the American primary results in Iowa.
I enjoyed it all … the drama, the outspoken political rivalries, the spins, the emotions, the partisan enthusiasm, the political involvement of all the volunteers, the campaign strategists, the media reporters and analysts … and, most of all, the voters who cared enough to take part.
But let’s keep it real.
In terms of IMPACT or EFFECT overall or in the long term, it reminds me of that quote from Shakespeare’s Macbeth:
“Life’s but a walking shadow, a poor player
That struts and frets his hour upon the stage
And then is heard no more: it is a tale
Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,
OK…we can hopefully forget the idiot part: I am but a blogger! :) And although I wouldn’t say the signify “nothing” , the truth is, in the overall picture, they signify very little.
The TRUTH is … two by-elections and one, two, three or four caucus primary vote results more often than not count for almost nothing in the long game or actual selection or election processes that take place several months or a year from now.
In fact, by-elections often go against whichever party is in power: people are usually not impressed or happy with governments over a whole number of issues and by-elections give us a chance to “send a message” … without actually tossing them out; government promises, bribes and tax cuts etc. never flow generously in by-elections; and the campaign ads/spending etc. don’t flow anywhere close (thankfully!) to the levels we see at election time.
American primary elections are different … but only to some extent: the millions of bucks DO flow there; the Superpacs (what an AWFUL way to circumvent election spending rules!) DO spend millions; the campaigning does involve the aspring TOP party leaders; and the media … state-wide, nationally and internationally … cover the event almost 24-7.
In Iowa, the TOTAL turnout for both the Democratic and Republican primaries was 351,000 registered voters … out of a state population of more than 3 million ..in other words, about 10%.
In Coquitlam Burke Mountain, the turnout was also low … less than 7,000 out of more than 38,000 eligible voters; in Vancouver Mount Pleasant the turnout was about 8,800 …. out of an eligible 40,000.
Get the picture?
The outcomes were great news for the NDP’s Jodie Wickens in Coquitlam-Burke Mountain and the NDPs Melanie Mark in Vancouver Mount Pleasant … and who could blame party supporters everywhere from celebrating?
And yes, the Coquitlam change IS interesting, since the riding was a Liberal stronghold …but the margin of victory was only 626 votes …in a by-election.
So is there a BIG message in the results to seriously scare the Liberal government? Not really.
Just as in Iowa, the Cruz victory will signify very little once the FINAL voting all take place for the Republican nomination.
Yet …in the end … even though I get as absorbed and almost as excited as the partisan party supporters do when the results start of flow … I know that down the very long road to power, what we saw this week …. in BC and in Iowa …. were really very small steps.
With lots of travel kilometres and miles to go before we even see ANY finish line.
(Reminder: Please don’t buy Japanese products …no matter how small or large: support the boycott to STOP Japan’s totally illegal slaughter of whales.
Also a reminder you can get FIRST ALERTS of any new posting on this Blog by following @harveyoberfeld on Twitter.)
Tags: British Columbia · International